Policy On Generative Ai And Publication Ethics

Policy On Generative Ai And Publication Ethics

1. Background & Reference Standards

These ethical guidelines govern the use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Generative AI) tools and AI-assisted technologies by authors, peer reviewers, and editors of the Journal of Applied Management and Business (JAMB). This policy has been formulated in accordance with international standards for scientific publication ethics, specifically referencing guidelines established by Elsevier.

2. Policy for Authors

    No AI Authorship: Generative AI tools (such as ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, Claude, and similar technologies) must not be listed or credited as an author or co-author. Authorship requires legal accountability for the content of the manuscript, consent for copyright licensing, and a guarantee of work integrity responsibilities that can only be fulfilled by humans.

    Permissible Use: Authors are permitted to use AI tools responsibly to assist with language refinement, grammar checking, readability enhancement, idea exploration, literature classification, interactive searching, and coding assistance. Authors are required to review and verify all AI outputs thoroughly to ensure accuracy and to prevent factual errors (hallucination) or bias.

    Prohibited Use:

        Images and Data: It is strictly prohibited to use AI to create or manipulate images, figures, graphics, charts, data tables, formulae, or computer code.

        Unverified Text/Data Generation: Submitting manuscripts containing AI-generated text or code without rigorous review by the author, or using synthetic data to replace missing empirical data without a valid scientific methodology, is strictly prohibited.

    Mandatory Disclosure & Transparency: Authors who utilise AI tools must include a formal written disclosure statement within the manuscript under the Methods or Acknowledgements section.

 

3. Policy for Peer Reviewers & Editors

    Protection of Confidentiality & Copyright: Editors and peer reviewers are strictly prohibited from uploading unpublished manuscripts, supplementary files, research data, or images into third-party Generative AI platforms. Doing so risks breaching manuscript confidentiality, proprietary copyright, and author data privacy.

    Independent Evaluation: Peer reviewers are prohibited from using AI to summarise manuscripts or to make peer-review decisions. The use of AI by reviewers is permitted solely to assist in refining the language quality of their review reports, while full responsibility for the evaluation remains entirely with the reviewer.

 

4. Editorial Oversight and Sanctions

    Maintaining Confidentiality: Editors are bound by the same strict obligation not to upload authors' manuscript files into external AI systems.

    Oversight and Sanctions: The Editorial Board reserves the right to investigate and take editorial action regarding any suspected ethical violations or breaches of this policy.

    Effective Date: This policy will formally take effect starting from the July 2027 issue (Vol. 8 No. 1) to provide a fair transition and dissemination period for authors who are currently preparing or have submitted manuscripts. This policy will be continuously updated in accordance with technological advancements and evolving international scientific ethics standards.


Ethics On The Use Of Generative Ai

1. Ethical Risks of Generative AI in Scholarly Publishing

The use of Generative AI tools in scientific research and scholarly publication presents several critical publication ethics risks that must be carefully addressed:

  • Inaccuracy and Bias (Hallucination): Generative AI tools are fundamentally statistical rather than factual in nature. Consequently, they can introduce errors regarding empirical facts, produce false information (hallucinations), or generate biases that are difficult to detect.
  • Lack of Attribution: AI tools frequently fail to adhere to established scholarly practices regarding proper citation and precise reference attribution.
  • Confidentiality and Intellectual Property Risks: The use of third-party AI platforms carries the risk of storing, disseminating, or repurposing user-submitted data, which may violate manuscript confidentiality and copyright protections.

 

2. Ethics for Authors

  • No AI Authorship: Generative AI tools must not be recognised, listed, or credited as an author or co-author. Authorship necessitates legal accountability for the manuscript's content, consent to copyright licensing agreements, and a guarantee of work integrity—responsibilities that can only be fulfilled by humans.
  • Permissible Use: Authors are permitted to utilise AI tools for language refinement, grammar checking, readability enhancement, idea exploration, literature classification, interactive searching, and coding assistance.
  • Prohibited Use:

(a)     Images and Data: It is strictly prohibited to use AI to create or manipulate images, figures, graphics, charts, data tables, formulae, or computer code.

(b)     Unevaluated AI-Generated Text & Synthetic Data: Submitting manuscripts containing AI-generated text or code without rigorous scientific revision by the author, or using synthetic data to substitute for original empirical research data without a valid methodology, is strictly prohibited.

  • Mandatory Disclosure & Transparency: Authors who utilise AI tools must explicitly include a formal written disclosure statement within the manuscript under the Methods or Acknowledgements section. This declaration must specify the full name of the AI tool (along with its version number), the rationale for its use, and how it was employed. Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, validity, and accuracy of the entire manuscript content.

 

3. Ethics for Peer Reviewers & Editors

  • Protection of Confidentiality & Copyright: Editors and peer reviewers are strictly prohibited from uploading unpublished manuscripts, research data, images, or manuscript details into third-party Generative AI systems. Such uploads breach manuscript confidentiality, author data privacy, and proprietary copyright.
  • Independent Review Evaluation: Peer reviewers are prohibited from using AI to summarise, assess, or make peer-review decisions regarding submitted manuscripts. The use of AI by reviewers is permitted solely to assist in enhancing the language quality of their review reports, with full responsibility for scientific evaluation remaining strictly with the human reviewer possessing expertise in their respective field.

 

4. Editorial Oversight and Transparency

  • Human Oversight: Transparency and editorial oversight must guide the deployment of AI technologies throughout every stage of research and publication.
  • Editorial Investigation: Any use of AI that violates ethical boundaries (such as image/data manipulation or unreviewed text generation) may be subject to editorial investigation and sanctions by the Editorial Board.